Name Class Date

EARTH EXPLAINED · LESSON GUIDE

The Night the Sky Caught Fire

The Carrington Event, 1859: how a storm on the Sun lit the night sky and ran a telegraph line

Video 8:41Level Grades 6–12 · Introductory university physics and Earth scienceStandards MS-ESS1-3, MS-PS2-5, MS-ESS3-2, HS-ESS1-1, HS-PS2-5, HS-ESS3-1
Play fromfor school networks that block YouTube

How could a storm on the Sun, 93 million miles (150 million km) away, light the night sky as far south as Cuba and Chile, and keep a telegraph line between Boston and Portland, Maine, running for more than two hours with no batteries at all?

Just after 11 a.m. London time on September 1, 1859, the English astronomer Richard Carrington, tracing sunspots from a projected image of the Sun, saw two patches of brilliant white light burst out of a sunspot group: the first solar flare anyone ever recorded. Less than a day later, one of the strongest geomagnetic storms ever recorded, perhaps the strongest, struck Earth. This lesson uses the Carrington Event to explain what sunspots and flares are, why the storm was caused not by the flare's light but by a coronal mass ejection that crossed 93 million miles (150 million km) in about 17.6 hours, how Earth's magnetic field shields us and how a storm breaks through, why the aurora spread to Cuba, Jamaica, Mexico and Chile, and how a changing magnetic field pushed current through telegraph wires. It ends with what a storm like it would do to power grids, satellites and GPS today, from Quebec's 1989 blackout to the near miss of July 2012, and with how forecasters now watch the Sun around the clock and rate storms from G1 to G5.

Captions (.vtt)Captions (.srt)
Captions in 16 more languages

Learning objectives After this lesson, students can:

  1. Describe what Richard Carrington observed on September 1, 1859, explain why it is called the first recorded solar flare, and explain why he was careful not to claim it caused the storm.
  2. Explain what sunspots are, why they look dark although they are thousands of degrees hot, and how the snapping of tangled magnetic loops releases a solar flare.
  3. Distinguish a solar flare (light and X-rays that reach Earth in about 8 minutes) from a coronal mass ejection (a cloud of charged gas that usually takes 1 to 4 days), and identify which one causes a geomagnetic storm.
  4. Explain how Earth's magnetic field usually turns the Sun's gas aside, and why a CME whose magnetism points the opposite way can pour energy in and set off a geomagnetic storm.
  5. Explain how the aurora forms, why its colors change with height, why in a great storm it spreads toward the equator, and why people far from the poles mostly see red.
  6. Use the idea of electromagnetic induction to explain how a changing magnetic field drove current through telegraph wires in 1859, and how storm currents threaten power grids today, as in Quebec in 1989.
  7. Evaluate the risks a Carrington-class storm would pose to power grids, satellites and GPS, and explain how coronagraphs, spacecraft a million miles (1.5 million km) out and the G1 to G5 scale give warning.

Before watching

Key vocabulary ★ extension terms for older students

Sunspot
A dark patch on the Sun's surface where its magnetism is tangled and strong. A sunspot looks dark only because it is thousands of degrees cooler than the blazing surface around it; a big one is wider than the whole Earth.
Solar flare
A sudden burst of energy from the Sun's magnetism, released when tangled magnetic loops above sunspots snap into a new shape. Its light and X-rays reach Earth in about 8 minutes. Carrington's flare of September 1, 1859 is the first ever recorded.
X-rays
Light of very high energy, invisible to the eye. A flare's X-rays reach Earth with its visible light and can jolt electric currents in the high air on Earth's sunlit side, which is what moved the magnetic needles at Kew in 1859.
Coronal mass ejection (CME)
A huge cloud of hot, electrically charged gas, laced with magnetism, thrown off the Sun. A big one can weigh a billion tons or more. Most take 1 to 4 days to reach Earth; Carrington's took about 17.6 hours.
Solar wind★
The steady flow of charged gas that streams outward from the Sun in all directions. Earth's magnetic field turns most of it aside, the way a rock splits a stream.
Magnetosphere★
The region of space around Earth controlled by Earth's magnetic field, which wraps the planet like a bubble and shields it from most of the Sun's gas.
Geomagnetic storm
A storm in Earth's magnetic field, set off when a CME whose magnetism points opposite to Earth's links up with Earth's field and pours energy in. It drives aurora far from the poles and electric currents in long wires.
Aurora
Air glowing high above the poles, about 60 to 250 miles (100 to 400 km) up, lit by charged particles from space. Oxygen glows green and, higher up, red; nitrogen adds touches of blue and purple near the bottom.
Sunspot cycle
The rise and fall of the Sun's spots and storms over about eleven years. 1859 was near a peak.
Magnetometer★
An instrument that tracks Earth's magnetism. At Kew Observatory, west of London, the magnetometers' needles gave a sudden jerk at almost the same moment as Carrington's flare.
Electromagnetic induction★
A changing magnetic field pushes electric current through a conductor. During a geomagnetic storm, Earth's swinging magnetic field pushes current through any long wire, such as a telegraph line or a power line.
Geomagnetically induced current (GIC)★
The electric current a geomagnetic storm pushes through long conductors on the ground, such as telegraph lines, power lines and pipelines. Storm currents can overheat the giant transformers that power grids depend on.
Transformer
A device that changes the voltage of electricity on a power grid. The giant transformers grids depend on can overheat when storm currents flow into them.
Coronagraph★
A telescope that blocks the bright disk of the Sun so that the fainter gas around it can be seen. Coronagraphs on spacecraft can see a CME leave the Sun, giving from less than a day to about three days of warning.
G-scale (geomagnetic storm scale)
NOAA's scale for rating geomagnetic storms, from G1 (minor) to G5 (extreme). A storm like Carrington's would top the scale and go far past an ordinary G5.

Chapter outline Select a time to play from there

0:00September 1859

In the early hours of September 2, 1859, the sky over New England blazed with aurora, so bright across the northeast that people could read ordinary print by it. That morning a telegraph operator in Boston asked Portland, Maine, to cut off its battery; both ends unplugged, and for more than two hours the line ran on power from the sky.

0:58A Flash on the Sun

On September 1, 1859, at 11:18 a.m. London time, Richard Carrington, drawing sunspots from a projected image of the Sun, saw two patches of brilliant white light burst out of a sunspot group; the flash lasted about five minutes. Richard Hodgson saw it too, and at almost the same moment the magnetic needles at Kew Observatory jumped. Sunspots are places of tangled, strong magnetism, thousands of degrees cooler than the surface around them, and when the tangled loops snap into a new shape they release a solar flare: Carrington's was the first ever recorded. He was careful ("one swallow does not make a summer"), but we now know the flare's X-rays jolted currents in the high air and moved the needles.

2:29From the Sun to Earth

A flare's light reaches Earth in about 8 minutes, but a big flare often comes with a coronal mass ejection, a cloud of charged gas laced with magnetism that can weigh a billion tons or more. Most CMEs take 1 to 4 days to cross the 93 million miles (150 million km); Carrington's took about 17.6 hours, more than 5 million mph (about 8.5 million km/h). Earth's magnetic field usually turns the Sun's gas aside, but a CME whose magnetism points the opposite way links up with it and sets off a geomagnetic storm. 1859 was near a peak of the eleven-year sunspot cycle, and a first storm on August 28–29 had, scientists think, swept the path clear.

4:03The Night the Sky Caught Fire

Earth's field steers charged particles toward the poles, where they make the air glow 60 to 250 miles (100 to 400 km) up: green oxygen, red oxygen higher up, and touches of blue and purple from nitrogen near the bottom. In a big storm the auroral rings spread toward the equator, and in 1859 the aurora was seen in Cuba, Jamaica, Mexico and Chile, mostly as red, the highest part of the glow. Earth's swinging magnetic field also pushed current through long wires: during that week's storms sparks jumped from telegraph equipment and operators got shocks, and the storm's own current ran the Boston–Portland line.

5:34If It Happened Again

Today a big storm can disrupt power grids, satellites and GPS. In Quebec on March 13, 1989, a smaller storm collapsed the grid in about a minute and a half, leaving about 6 million people without power for about 9 hours, and studies warn a Carrington-class storm could cut power across whole regions, in the worst places for weeks. In February 2022 a minor storm brought down 38 new satellites, and on July 23, 2012 a CME at least as strong as Carrington's missed Earth; had it erupted about a week earlier, it would have been aimed at us. Coronagraphs now give from less than a day to about three days of warning, spacecraft a million miles (1.5 million km) out give 15 to 60 minutes (about 10 for a Carrington-fast cloud), and storms are rated G1 to G5.

7:54What to Remember

Carrington saw a solar flare, a burst of energy from the Sun's tangled magnetism. A cloud of charged gas followed it to Earth in less than a day and set off a storm in Earth's magnetic field, which lit the sky far from the poles and pushed current through the wires. Forecasters now watch the Sun every minute of every day for the next one.

Common misconceptions For the teacher

MisconceptionThe light from Carrington's flare caused the great storm.

What the evidence showsThe flare's light and X-rays reached Earth in about 8 minutes and caused only a brief jolt in the magnetic needles at Kew. The great storm came about 17.6 hours later, when the coronal mass ejection, a cloud of charged gas laced with magnetism, arrived and linked up with Earth's magnetic field.

MisconceptionThe aurora only happens near the North and South Poles.

What the evidence showsOn most nights the aurora stays in rings around each pole, but in a big storm the rings grow and spread toward the equator: the more energy pours in, the wider they spread. In 1859 people saw the aurora in Cuba, Jamaica, Mexico and Chile.

MisconceptionSolar storms are rare, once-in-history events.

What the evidence showsStorms happen all the time; it is storms as strong as Carrington's that are rare. NOAA's scale lists about 1,700 minor (G1) storms in an average eleven-year sunspot cycle, and even a minor storm brought down 38 new satellites in February 2022. Great storms that came close to Carrington's struck in 1872 and 1921, a smaller storm blacked out Quebec in 1989, and in July 2012 a CME at least as strong as Carrington's missed Earth.

MisconceptionSunspots are dark because they are cold, or because they are holes in the Sun.

What the evidence showsSunspots are places where the Sun's magnetism is tangled and strong. They are still thousands of degrees hot; they look dark only because they are thousands of degrees cooler than the blazing surface around them.

MisconceptionEarth's magnetic field always blocks the Sun's storms.

What the evidence showsMost of the time the field turns the Sun's gas aside, the way a rock splits a stream. But when a CME's own magnetism points the opposite way, it links up with Earth's field and pours energy in, setting off a geomagnetic storm.

MisconceptionThe Carrington Event was certainly the strongest geomagnetic storm in history.

What the evidence showsIt was one of the strongest ever recorded, perhaps the strongest. Storms in February 1872 and May 1921 came close, and estimates of the strength of 19th-century storms are uncertain enough that no one can rank them with confidence.

MisconceptionIf a storm like Carrington's came today, it would hit without warning.

What the evidence showsSpacecraft now watch the Sun around the clock. Seeing a CME leave the Sun gives from less than a day to about three days of warning, and spacecraft about a million miles (1.5 million km) out give a final warning, usually 15 minutes to an hour, so grid operators can shift power and satellite teams can put spacecraft into safe modes.

Discussion questions

  1. Carrington saw the flash and the jumping needles at Kew, but wrote that "one swallow does not make a summer". Was he right to be cautious? What kind of evidence would scientists need before they could say that flares and magnetic storms are linked?
  2. In 1859 the telegraph was the only electric network, and the storm's main effects were sparks, shocks and a line that ran without batteries. Today we depend on power grids, satellites and GPS. Make a list of the services in your town that would stop if the power went out for a day, and for a week. Which would matter most, and to whom?
  3. In July 2012 a CME at least as strong as Carrington's missed Earth; had it erupted about a week earlier, it would have been aimed at us. Should a near miss like this change how governments and power companies prepare? Why do you think near misses often get less attention than disasters?
  4. A final warning from spacecraft a million miles (1.5 million km) out might give 15 to 60 minutes, and only about 10 minutes for a cloud as fast as Carrington's. What could a grid operator, a satellite team, an airline or a hospital usefully do with ten minutes, and with an hour?
  5. Most people far from the poles have never seen the aurora. If the sky over your town glowed red one night, how would you find out what was happening, and what would you tell your family? How do you think people in 1859, with no explanation, reacted?
  6. Forecasters rate storms from G1 to G5, but a Carrington-class storm would go far past an ordinary G5. What are the strengths and weaknesses of a scale that tops out at 5? How does it compare with other hazard scales you know, such as hurricane categories?

Quiz Choose an answer; it checks itself

1.What did Richard Carrington see on September 1, 1859?

2.Why do sunspots look dark?

3.At almost the same moment as Carrington's flare, the magnetic needles at Kew Observatory jumped. What do scientists now think moved them?

4.Which of these reached Earth about 17.6 hours after Carrington saw the flash?

5.When does a CME set off a strong geomagnetic storm?

6.In 1859, where was the aurora seen far from the poles?

7.Why did most people far from the poles see a red aurora rather than a green one?

8.How did the Boston–Portland telegraph line keep working with its batteries disconnected?

9.What happened in Quebec on March 13, 1989?

10.Spacecraft about a million miles (1.5 million km) from Earth measure a CME's magnetism as it passes. How much warning does that usually give?

Written response

1. Tell the story of the Carrington Event from the Sun to the telegraph wires, in order, and say how long each step took. Make clear which part was the flare and which part caused the storm.

What a strong answer includes

Tangled magnetic loops above a sunspot group snapped into a new shape and released a solar flare, which Carrington saw at 11:18 a.m. London time on September 1, 1859, as two patches of white light lasting about five minutes. The flare's light and X-rays reached Earth in about 8 minutes; the X-rays jolted currents in the high air and moved the needles at Kew. The flare came with a coronal mass ejection, a cloud of charged gas laced with magnetism, which crossed the 93 million miles (150 million km) in about 17.6 hours. Its magnetism linked up with Earth's field and poured energy in, setting off a geomagnetic storm on September 2. The storm drove particles into the high air to make aurora seen as far as Cuba, Jamaica, Mexico and Chile, and its swinging magnetic field pushed current through telegraph wires. The flare was the flash; the CME caused the storm.

2. On the morning of September 2, 1859, the telegraph line between Boston and Portland, Maine, ran for more than two hours with no batteries. Explain where its power came from, and why a long wire was more affected than a short one.

What a strong answer includes

During the geomagnetic storm, Earth's magnetic field was swinging back and forth. A changing magnetic field pushes electric current through any conductor in it (electromagnetic induction), so the storm pushed its own current down the wire, enough to carry the messages once both ends had cut off their batteries. The push builds up along the whole length of the wire, so the longer the wire, the larger the voltage the storm could produce between its ends. The same effect made sparks jump from telegraph equipment and gave operators shocks during that week's storms, and today it drives currents into the long power lines and transformers of power grids.

3. A classmate says the red glow seen over Cuba and Chile in 1859 could not have been the aurora, because the aurora happens only near the poles and is green. Explain why both parts of this claim are wrong.

What a strong answer includes

The aurora usually sits in rings around each pole, but in a great storm the rings grow and spread toward the equator: the more energy pours in, the wider they spread, and in 1859 they reached Cuba, Jamaica, Mexico and Chile. The aurora is not only green: oxygen glows green lower down and red higher up, about 60 to 250 miles (100 to 400 km) above the ground overall, with touches of blue and purple from nitrogen near the bottom. Someone far from the glow sees only its highest part over the horizon, which is the red, so a red glow low in the sky is exactly what people far from the poles should see.

4. Describe three ways a storm like Carrington's could disrupt modern life, with an example from a real storm for each, and explain what forecasters and operators can now do about it.

What a strong answer includes

Power grids: storm currents flow into long power lines and can overheat giant transformers; in Quebec on March 13, 1989, a smaller storm collapsed the grid in about a minute and a half, leaving about 6 million people without power for about 9 hours, and studies warn a Carrington-class storm could cut power across whole regions, in the worst places for weeks. Satellites: the storm heats and swells the upper air, which drags on satellites; in February 2022 a minor storm brought down 38 new satellites. GPS: its signals pass through the charged upper air, so positions can drift or drop out. Forecasters now watch the Sun around the clock: coronagraphs give from less than a day to about three days of warning, spacecraft about a million miles (1.5 million km) out give 15 to 60 minutes (about 10 for a Carrington-fast cloud), and storms are rated G1 to G5. Grid operators can shift power, and satellite teams can put spacecraft into safe modes until it passes.

Going deeper University and advanced high school

How fast was Carrington's CME?

The Sun is about 93 million miles (1.50 × 108 km) from Earth. Light, at about 3.00 × 105 km/s (186,000 mi/s), makes the trip in about 8 minutes 20 seconds. Most CMEs take 1 to 4 days; Carrington's took about 17.6 hours (Cliver and Svalgaard, 2004). A big CME can weigh a billion tons or more; take 1 × 1012 kg (a billion metric tons, 2.2 × 1012 lb) for the estimate. A transit time gives an average speed: a real CME's speed changes on the way.

Problem(a) Calculate the average speed of Carrington's CME in mph and in km/s, and check the lecture's "more than five million miles an hour". (b) Calculate the average speeds of CMEs that take 1 day and 4 days. (c) How many times longer than sunlight did Carrington's CME take? (d) Estimate the kinetic energy of a 1012 kg (2.2 × 1012 lb) CME at Carrington's speed, and compare it with a 4-day CME of the same mass.

Worked answer

(a) 93 × 106 mi ÷ 17.6 h ≈ 5.3 million mph. 17.6 h = 63,360 s, so 1.50 × 108 km ÷ 63,360 s ≈ 2,370 km/s (1,470 mi/s), about 8.5 million km/h. (b) 1 day = 86,400 s: 1.50 × 108 ÷ 86,400 ≈ 1,740 km/s (1,080 mi/s). 4 days = 345,600 s: ≈ 434 km/s (270 mi/s). (c) 63,360 s ÷ 500 s ≈ 127 times longer. (d) KE = ½mv² = ½ × 1012 × (2.37 × 106 m/s)² ≈ 2.8 × 1024 J. At 434 km/s, KE ≈ ½ × 1012 × (4.34 × 105)² ≈ 9.4 × 1022 J. Kinetic energy grows with the square of speed, so (2,370 ÷ 434)² ≈ 30 times more.

How much warning from a million miles out?

Spacecraft about 1.5 × 106 km (930,000 mi) from Earth, between the Sun and Earth, measure a CME's magnetism as it passes them. That gives a final warning before the cloud reaches Earth, and tells forecasters whether its magnetism points the way that links up with Earth's field. NOAA gives a usual final warning of 15 to 60 minutes. Coronagraphs, which see a CME leave the Sun, give earlier notice: from less than a day to about three days. Assume the CME keeps its average speed over the last stretch.

Problem(a) Calculate the warning time from the spacecraft for a CME with Carrington's average speed (about 2,370 km/s, 1,470 mi/s). (b) Calculate it for CMEs that take 1 day and 4 days to reach Earth (about 1,740 and 434 km/s, or 1,080 and 270 mi/s). Do your results agree with "15 to 60 minutes"? (c) Why does the final warning matter, even when a coronagraph has already seen the CME leave the Sun?

Worked answer

(a) t = 1.5 × 106 km ÷ 2,370 km/s ≈ 630 s (in miles: 930,000 mi ÷ 1,470 mi/s), about 10.5 minutes: the lecture's "closer to ten minutes". (b) 1.5 × 106 ÷ 1,740 ≈ 860 s ≈ 14 minutes; 1.5 × 106 ÷ 434 ≈ 3,460 s ≈ 58 minutes. That matches the usual range of 15 to 60 minutes. (c) A coronagraph shows that a cloud is coming and roughly when, but not which way its magnetism points. The storm's strength depends on whether the CME's field points opposite to Earth's, and that can only be measured when the cloud reaches the spacecraft.

Why a sunspot looks dark

A hot surface radiates power per square meter j = σT⁴ (the Stefan–Boltzmann law, σ = 5.67 × 10-8 W m^-2 K^-4), and its spectrum peaks at the wavelength λ_max = b ÷ T (Wien's law, b = 2.898 × 10-3 m·K). The Sun's surface is about 5,800 K (about 5,500 °C, 10,000 °F); the dark centre (umbra) of a sunspot is about 3,500 to 4,000 K, thousands of degrees cooler.

Problem(a) What fraction of the power per square meter of the normal surface does a sunspot's umbra radiate, at 3,500 K and at 4,000 K? (b) Find the peak wavelength for 5,800 K and for 4,000 K. (c) Use your answers to explain the lecture's statement that sunspots "look dark only because" they are cooler. Would a sunspot look dark if you could see it alone against the night sky?

Worked answer

(a) (3,500 ÷ 5,800)⁴ ≈ 0.13 and (4,000 ÷ 5,800)⁴ ≈ 0.23: the umbra radiates about 13% to 23% as much per square meter. (b) b = 2.898 × 106 nm·K, so 2.898 × 106 ÷ 5,800 ≈ 500 nm (visible green-blue); 2.898 × 106 ÷ 4,000 ≈ 720 nm (deep red to near infrared). (c) The umbra still radiates σT⁴ ≈ 5.67 × 10-8 × 4,000⁴ ≈ 1.5 × 107 W per square meter, far more than any lamp. It looks dark only by contrast with the surface around it, which is four to eight times brighter. Seen alone against the night sky, a sunspot would glow brilliantly, orange-red.

Why the red aurora shows from far away

The aurora glows about 60 to 250 miles (100 to 400 km) up: green oxygen low, red oxygen at the top. A point at height h above a sphere of radius R can be seen from the ground out to a distance of about d = √(2Rh) (ignoring the bending of light by the air, and taking h much smaller than R). Earth's radius is about 3,960 miles (6,371 km).

Problem(a) How far away, along the ground, can someone see the top of a glow at 250 miles (400 km), on the horizon? (b) How far for the bottom of the aurora, at 60 miles (100 km)? (c) Use your answers to explain why observers in Cuba, Jamaica, Mexico and Chile mostly saw red, low on the horizon.

Worked answer

(a) d = √(2 × 6,371 × 400) ≈ √5,100,000 ≈ 2,260 km, or √(2 × 3,960 × 250) ≈ 1,410 miles. (b) d = √(2 × 6,371 × 100) ≈ 1,130 km, or √(2 × 3,960 × 60) ≈ 690 miles. (c) The red top of the aurora can be seen about twice as far away as its green lower part. An observer more than about 700 miles (1,100 km) from the ground beneath the aurora, but less than about 1,400 miles (2,260 km), sees only the red top above the horizon, with the green hidden below it. That is why, far from the poles, the 1859 aurora appeared mostly as a red glow low in the sky.

Faraday's law and the long wire

Faraday's law of induction says that a changing magnetic flux through a circuit induces an electromotive force ε = −dΦ/dt, where Φ = B·A for a uniform field B through an area A. During a geomagnetic storm, Earth's field swings by hundreds of nanoteslas (1 nT = 10-9 T). Equivalently, the changing field induces an electric field E in the ground and along a line, and the voltage between the ends of a straight line of length L is about E × L. The numbers below are chosen for the exercise; they are not measurements from 1859.

Problem(a) A circuit encloses a rectangle 100 km (62 mi) long and 10 km (6.2 mi) wide. The magnetic field through it changes steadily by 500 nT in 5 minutes. Calculate the average induced emf. (b) What happens to the emf if the rectangle is 200 km (124 mi) long, or if the same change happens in 2.5 minutes? (c) The wire's resistance grows in proportion to its length. If the wire's own resistance is all that limits the current, how does the current change when the circuit is twice as long? Use this to explain the lecture's wording, "the longer the wire, the harder the storm could push". (d) Why are modern power lines, with very low resistance, more exposed to large storm currents than a thin telegraph wire?

Worked answer

(a) A = 1.0 × 105 m × 1.0 × 104 m = 1.0 × 109 m² (about 390 sq mi). ΔΦ = 5.0 × 10-7 T × 1.0 × 109 m² = 500 Wb. ε = 500 Wb ÷ 300 s ≈ 1.7 V. (b) Doubling the length doubles the area and the emf, to about 3.3 V; halving the time doubles the rate of change, also giving about 3.3 V. (c) Twice the length gives twice the emf but also about twice the resistance, so I = ε ÷ R stays about the same. The length sets the voltage, the "push", not the current. (d) Current is the push divided by the resistance. Power lines are very long, so the push is large, and they are built with very low resistance, so the same push drives a much larger current, which flows through the grounded transformers at each end and can overheat them.

Measuring a storm: the Dst index and the G-scale

The Dst (disturbance storm time) index measures, roughly every hour, how much the horizontal magnetic field at stations near the equator is weakened during a storm, by a ring of electric current that circles Earth. The more negative Dst, the stronger the storm. Estimates: September 1859, about −850 nT (Siscoe and others, 2006); May 1921, about −907 ± 132 nT (Love and others, 2019). Earth's field at the surface near the equator is about 30,000 nT. NOAA's G-scale rates storms by the Kp index, which runs from 0 to 9: G1 (minor) is Kp 5, about 1,700 storms in an average eleven-year cycle; G5 (extreme) is Kp 9, about 4 per cycle.

Problem(a) By what percentage did the 1859 storm weaken the field near the equator? (b) Compare the 1859 and 1921 estimates, including the uncertainty. Can you say which storm was stronger? (c) On average, how many G1 storms happen per year, and how many years pass between G5 storms? (d) Why does the lecture say a storm like Carrington's would "go far past an ordinary G5"?

Worked answer

(a) 850 ÷ 30,000 ≈ 0.028, about a 3% weakening, a small fraction, but an enormous change by the standard of magnetic storms. (b) −907 ± 132 nT spans about −775 to −1,039 nT, which includes −850 nT. The estimates overlap, and the 19th-century estimate is itself uncertain, so the storms cannot be ranked with confidence. That is why the lecture calls 1859 one of the strongest ever recorded, "perhaps the strongest". (c) 1,700 ÷ 11 ≈ 150 minor storms a year, about three a week on average (they cluster near the cycle's peak). 11 ÷ 4 ≈ 3 years between G5 storms on average. (d) Kp stops at 9, so every storm from an ordinary extreme storm upward is a G5. The scale cannot tell a Carrington-class storm from a G5 that occurs every few years; Dst, which has no top, can.

Standards alignment

Next Generation Science Standards

MS-ESS1-3

Analyze and interpret data to determine scale properties of objects in the solar system.

In this episode: The 93 million miles (150 million km) from the Sun to Earth, drawn to scale; sunspots wider than the whole Earth; Carrington's drawing of the sunspot group as data.

MS-PS2-5

Conduct an investigation and evaluate the experimental design to provide evidence that fields exist between objects exerting forces on each other even though the objects are not in contact.

In this episode: The Kew magnetic needles jumping during the flare and storm; Earth's magnetic field as an invisible shield that turns the Sun's gas aside.

MS-ESS3-2

Analyze and interpret data on natural hazards to forecast future catastrophic events and inform the development of technologies to mitigate their effects.

In this episode: The sunspot cycle, coronagraph and L1 warnings, the G1 to G5 scale, and the protective steps grid operators and satellite teams take.

HS-ESS1-1

Develop a model based on evidence to illustrate the life span of the sun and the role of nuclear fusion in the sun's core to release energy that eventually reaches Earth in the form of radiation.

In this episode: Its clarification statement names the ways the Sun's radiation varies due to sudden solar flares ("space weather") and the 11-year sunspot cycle as evidence: Carrington's flare, its X-rays and the cycle near its 1859 peak.

HS-PS2-5

Plan and conduct an investigation to provide evidence that an electric current can produce a magnetic field and that a changing magnetic field can produce an electric current.

In this episode: Earth's swinging magnetic field pushing current through the Boston–Portland telegraph line and, today, into power lines and transformers (Quebec, 1989).

HS-ESS3-1

Construct an explanation based on evidence for how the availability of natural resources, occurrence of natural hazards, and changes in climate have influenced human activity.

In this episode: From a telegraph network in 1859 to modern dependence on power grids, satellites and GPS; the Quebec blackout, the 2022 satellite losses and the 2012 near miss.

Advanced Placement

University courses

Introductory physics (electricity and magnetism)

Magnetic fields; Faraday's law of induction; induced emf, current and resistance; blackbody radiation (Stefan–Boltzmann and Wien laws) applied to sunspots

Space physics and heliophysics

Sunspots, solar flares and coronal mass ejections; the sunspot cycle; the magnetosphere and magnetic reconnection; the aurora; the Dst and Kp indices; space weather forecasting

Natural hazards and Earth science

Space weather as a natural hazard; historical storms (1859, 1872, 1921, 1989); geomagnetically induced currents in power grids; satellite drag and GPS errors; warning systems and preparedness

Transcript The narration, word for word

0:00September 1859

In the early hours of September 2, 1859, the night sky over New England blazed with light. Across the northeast, it was so bright that people could read ordinary print by it, in the middle of the night.

0:14That morning, a telegraph operator in Boston sent a strange request to Portland, Maine. Please cut off your battery, he tapped, and let's see if we can work with the aurora alone.

0:26Portland unplugged its battery, and Boston did the same. The messages kept coming, and Portland said the line worked even better. For more than two hours, the line ran on power from the sky. Where was that power coming from?

0:40In this lecture, we'll answer four questions. What did an astronomer in England see on the Sun? How does a storm on the Sun reach Earth? Why did the sky glow and the wires spark? And what would a storm like it do now?

0:58A Flash on the Sun

The day before, an English astronomer named Richard Carrington was drawing sunspots. He never looked at the Sun directly. He shone its image onto a screen, and traced the dark spots by hand.

1:13Just after 11 in the morning, something flared in one group of spots. Two patches of brilliant white light burst out, brighter than the Sun's own surface.

1:23Carrington ran to find someone else to see it. When he came back, the light was fading. The whole flash lasted about five minutes.

1:32In north London, another observer, Richard Hodgson, saw the same flash. And at almost the same moment, at Kew Observatory, west of London, the instruments that track Earth's magnetism gave a sudden jerk.

1:46Sunspots are places where the Sun's magnetism is tangled and strong. They look dark only because they're thousands of degrees cooler than the blazing surface around them. And they're huge: a big one is wider than the whole Earth.

2:01When those tangled loops snap into a new shape, they release a burst of energy, called a solar flare. Carrington had seen the first solar flare anyone ever recorded.

2:11He wondered if the flash and the jumping needles were linked. But he was careful. One swallow, he wrote, does not make a summer.

2:20We now know they were linked. The flare's X-rays reached Earth with its light, and jolted electric currents high in the air. That's what moved the needles.

2:29From the Sun to Earth

A flare is light, so it reaches us in about eight minutes, as fast as anything can travel. But a big flare often comes with something slower, and much bigger.

2:39The Sun can throw off a huge cloud of hot gas, made of electrically charged particles and laced with magnetism. It's called a coronal mass ejection, or CME. A big one can weigh 1 billion tons or more.

2:53The trip to Earth is 93 million miles, about 150 million kilometers. Most CMEs take one to four days to cross it.

3:02Carrington's CME made the trip in about 17.5 hours. That's more than 5 million miles an hour, about 8.5 million kilometers, one of the fastest ever measured.

3:14Earth has a shield: its magnetic field, which wraps the planet like a bubble. Most of the time, it turns the Sun's gas aside, the way a rock splits a stream.

3:25But when a CME's own magnetism points the opposite way, it links up with Earth's field, and pours energy in. That sets off a geomagnetic storm, a storm in Earth's magnetic field.

3:38That week, the Sun was unusually busy. Its spots and storms rise and fall on a cycle of about 11 years, and 1859 was near a peak.

3:48A first storm had already struck a few days before. Carrington's CME brought a second one, even stronger, less than a day after the flash. Scientists think the first cloud had swept the path clear.

4:03The Night the Sky Caught Fire

Earth's magnetic field steers some of that energy toward the poles. There, charged particles crash into the thin air, about 60 to 250 miles up, or 100 to 400 kilometers, and make it glow. That glow is the aurora.

4:19Oxygen glows green, and higher up, red. Nitrogen adds touches of blue and purple, near the bottom.

4:26Most nights, the aurora stays near the Arctic and the Antarctic, in rings around each pole. In a big storm, the rings grow, and spread toward the equator. The more energy pours in, the wider they spread.

4:39In 1859, they spread farther than almost anyone had seen. People saw the aurora in Cuba, Jamaica and Mexico, and far to the south, in Chile.

4:50That far from the poles, most people saw red. The red glow is the highest part of the aurora, so it shows over the horizon from far away.

4:59The storm did something else. Earth's magnetic field was swinging back and forth. And a changing magnetic field pushes electric current through any long wire, like a telegraph line.

5:11During that week's storms, sparks jumped from telegraph equipment, and operators got shocks. In Washington, one operator was stunned for an instant.

5:21That's where the line between Boston and Portland got its power. The storm was pushing its own current down the wire. The longer the wire, the harder the storm could push.

5:34If It Happened Again

In 1859, the telegraph was the only electric network. Now we depend on power grids, satellites and GPS. A big storm can disrupt all three.

5:48In March, 1989, a smaller storm reached Quebec, in Canada. Storm currents tripped the power grid, and it collapsed in about a minute and a half. Studies warn that a storm like Carrington's could cut power across whole regions, in the worst places for weeks.

6:04Power lines are like the old telegraph wires, only far longer, and they carry far more. Storm currents can overheat the giant transformers that power grids depend on. The biggest are built to order, and replacing one can take a year or more.

6:20The storm also heats the upper air, and it swells and drags on satellites. In 2022, even a minor storm brought 38 new satellites down. And GPS signals pass through that charged air, so they can drift, or drop out.

6:36In July, 2012, the Sun threw off a CME about as strong as Carrington's. It missed us. If it had erupted about a week earlier, it would have been aimed at Earth.

6:48Now, we watch the Sun around the clock. Spacecraft can see a CME leave the Sun, and that gives from less than a day to about three days of warning. Forecasters rate the storms coming, from G1, minor, to G5, extreme.

7:04About 1 million miles out, about 1.5 million kilometers, other spacecraft measure the cloud's magnetism as it passes. That gives a final warning, usually 15 minutes to an hour, so grid operators can protect the network. For a cloud as fast as Carrington's, it could be closer to ten minutes.

7:24A storm like Carrington's would top the scale at G5, and go far past an ordinary G5. Only a few on record, in 1872 and 1921, come close to it. Grid operators can shift power, and satellite teams can tuck their spacecraft into safe modes until it passes.

7:44So a storm like Carrington's will come again. One study puts the chance at less than 2% each decade. The difference is, now we can see it coming.

7:54What to Remember

So, here's what to remember: Carrington saw a solar flare, a burst of energy from the Sun's tangled magnetism. A cloud of charged gas followed it to Earth in less than a day, and set off a storm in Earth's magnetic field. That storm lit the sky far from the poles, and pushed current through the wires. And forecasters now watch for the next one.

8:16Carrington watched the flash for five minutes, with a pencil in his hand. Now, the Sun is watched every minute of every day. And if you ever see the night sky glow red or green, you'll know it started on the Sun.

Sources

  1. Carrington, R. C. (1859). Description of a singular appearance seen in the Sun on September 1, 1859. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 20, 13–15. doi.org/10.1093/mnras/20.1.13Used for: The flare: time, the two patches of white light, the projected image, "one swallow does not make a summer"
  2. Hodgson, R. (1859). On a curious appearance seen in the Sun. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 20, 15–16. doi.org/10.1093/mnras/20.1.15Used for: The independent sighting from Highgate
  3. Stewart, B. (1861). On the great magnetic disturbance which extended from August 28 to September 7, 1859, as recorded by photography at the Kew Observatory. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 151, 423–430. doi.org/10.1098/rstl.1861.0023Used for: The Kew magnetometers' jump at the time of the flare; the two storms
  4. Prescott, G. B. (1860). History, Theory, and Practice of the Electric Telegraph. Boston: Ticknor and Fields (auroral chapter). earlyradiohistory.us/1860auro.htmUsed for: The Boston–Portland line run without batteries; sparks and shocks; the Washington operator's shock (August 28)
  5. Green, J. L., Boardsen, S., Odenwald, S., Humble, J., & Pazamickas, K. A. (2006). Eyewitness reports of the great auroral storm of 1859. Advances in Space Research, 38(2), 145–154. doi.org/10.1016/j.asr.2005.12.021Used for: The two storms of that week; aurora bright enough to read print by in the northeastern US
  6. Hayakawa, H., et al. (2018). Low-latitude aurorae during the extreme space weather events in 1859. The Astrophysical Journal, 869, 57. arxiv.org/abs/1811.02786Used for: Aurora seen in Cuba, Jamaica, Mexico and Chile on September 1–2
  7. González-Esparza, J. A., & Cuevas-Cardona, M. C. (2018). Observations of low-latitude red aurora in Mexico during the 1859 Carrington geomagnetic storm. Space Weather, 16(12), 2038–2051. doi.org/10.1029/2018SW001995Used for: The red aurora seen from Mexico City
  8. Cliver, E. W., & Svalgaard, L. (2004). The 1859 solar–terrestrial disturbance and the current limits of extreme space weather activity. Solar Physics, 224, 407–422. doi.org/10.1007/s11207-005-4980-zUsed for: The CME's transit time of about 17.6 hours; the first storm clearing the path
  9. Tsurutani, B. T., Gonzalez, W. D., Lakhina, G. S., & Alex, S. (2003). The extreme magnetic storm of 1–2 September 1859. Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics, 108(A7), 1268. doi.org/10.1029/2002JA009504Used for: The storm's strength and the preceding storm
  10. Siscoe, G., Crooker, N. U., & Clauer, C. R. (2006). Dst of the Carrington storm of 1859. Advances in Space Research, 38(2), 173–179. ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2006AdSpR..38..173S/abstractUsed for: The storm's estimated Dst (about −850 nT)
  11. Love, J. J., Hayakawa, H., & Cliver, E. W. (2019). Intensity and impact of the New York Railroad superstorm of May 1921. Space Weather, 17(8), 1281–1292. doi.org/10.1029/2019SW002250Used for: The May 1921 storm (about −907 nT), comparable to 1859
  12. Hayakawa, H., et al. (2023). The extreme space weather event of 1872 February: sunspots, magnetic disturbance, and auroral displays. The Astrophysical Journal, 959(1), 23. doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/acc6ccUsed for: The February 1872 storm, comparable to 1859
  13. NOAA Space Weather Prediction Center. Coronal Mass Ejections; Aurora; Geomagnetic Storms. www.swpc.noaa.gov/phenomena/coronal-mass-ejectionsUsed for: CME mass and travel times; aurora heights and colors; warning times
  14. NOAA Space Weather Prediction Center. NOAA Space Weather Scales. www.swpc.noaa.gov/noaa-scales-explanationUsed for: The G1 to G5 scale, its Kp thresholds and average frequencies
  15. NASA. Sun: Facts. science.nasa.gov/sun/factsUsed for: The Sun–Earth distance, the travel time of light, sunspot sizes
  16. Hydro-Québec. In March 1989, Québec experienced a blackout caused by a solar storm. www.hydroquebec.com/learning/notions-de-base/tempete-mars-1989.htmlUsed for: The Quebec blackout of March 13, 1989: speed of the collapse and duration
  17. National Research Council (2008). Severe Space Weather Events: Understanding Societal and Economic Impacts: A Workshop Report. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. doi.org/10.17226/12507Used for: What a Carrington-class storm could do to power grids
  18. Lloyd's & Atmospheric and Environmental Research (2013). Solar Storm Risk to the North American Electric Grid. www.lloyds.com/insights/risk-reports/solar-stormUsed for: Regional, long-lasting power outages from a Carrington-class storm
  19. National Weather Service (2022). February 2022 geomagnetic storm and the loss of Starlink satellites. www.weather.gov/news/111522-starlinkUsed for: 38 new satellites lost after a minor storm in February 2022
  20. Baker, D. N., et al. (2013). A major solar eruptive event in July 2012: Defining extreme space weather scenarios. Space Weather, 11, 585–591. doi.org/10.1002/swe.20097Used for: The July 23, 2012 CME, at least as strong as Carrington's
  21. NASA Science (2014, July 23). Near Miss: The Solar Superstorm of July 2012. science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2014/23jul_superstormUsed for: The 2012 near miss and the timing that kept it from Earth

Images in the episode: USGS, NOAA and NASA (public domain), with maps from NASA/USGS Landsat via NASA GIBS; animations by EarthWatch 24-7. Full credits: earthwatch247.com/credits.html.

Cite this lesson

EarthWatch 24-7. (2026). The Night the Sky Caught Fire: The Carrington Event, 1859: how a storm on the Sun lit the night sky and ran a telegraph line [Video lesson]. Earth Explained: Space weather, case study. https://earthwatch247.com/learn/carrington-1859/

Answer key

  1. C. Projecting the Sun's image onto a screen, he saw two patches of white light flare up at 11:18 a.m. London time and fade within about five minutes: the first solar flare anyone ever recorded. Richard Hodgson saw it too.
  2. A. Sunspots are places where the Sun's magnetism is tangled and strong. They are still very hot, but cooler than their surroundings, so they look dark by contrast.
  3. D. Light and X-rays reach Earth in about 8 minutes, so the X-rays arrived with the flash and jolted currents in the high air on Earth's sunlit side. The CME took about 17.6 hours.
  4. B. Most CMEs take 1 to 4 days to cross the 93 million miles (150 million km). Carrington's did it in about 17.6 hours, more than 5 million mph (about 8.5 million km/h), one of the fastest ever measured.
  5. A. Most of the time Earth's magnetic field turns the Sun's gas aside, like a rock splitting a stream. A CME whose magnetism points the opposite way links up with Earth's field instead.
  6. C. In a big storm the auroral rings spread toward the equator, and in 1859 they spread farther than almost anyone had seen. Historical records document the aurora in Cuba, Jamaica, Mexico and Chile on September 1–2.
  7. B. Oxygen glows green lower down and red higher up. An observer far from the glow sees only its very top, the red, low on the horizon.
  8. D. A changing magnetic field pushes current through any long wire. For more than two hours on the morning of September 2, the storm's own current ran the line, and the longer the wire, the harder the storm could push.
  9. C. And the 1989 storm was smaller than Carrington's. Studies warn that a storm like Carrington's could cut power across whole regions, in the worst places for weeks.
  10. A. This is the final warning. Coronagraphs, which see a CME leave the Sun, give earlier notice: from less than a day to about three days.

Written response

  1. Tangled magnetic loops above a sunspot group snapped into a new shape and released a solar flare, which Carrington saw at 11:18 a.m. London time on September 1, 1859, as two patches of white light lasting about five minutes. The flare's light and X-rays reached Earth in about 8 minutes; the X-rays jolted currents in the high air and moved the needles at Kew. The flare came with a coronal mass ejection, a cloud of charged gas laced with magnetism, which crossed the 93 million miles (150 million km) in about 17.6 hours. Its magnetism linked up with Earth's field and poured energy in, setting off a geomagnetic storm on September 2. The storm drove particles into the high air to make aurora seen as far as Cuba, Jamaica, Mexico and Chile, and its swinging magnetic field pushed current through telegraph wires. The flare was the flash; the CME caused the storm.
  2. During the geomagnetic storm, Earth's magnetic field was swinging back and forth. A changing magnetic field pushes electric current through any conductor in it (electromagnetic induction), so the storm pushed its own current down the wire, enough to carry the messages once both ends had cut off their batteries. The push builds up along the whole length of the wire, so the longer the wire, the larger the voltage the storm could produce between its ends. The same effect made sparks jump from telegraph equipment and gave operators shocks during that week's storms, and today it drives currents into the long power lines and transformers of power grids.
  3. The aurora usually sits in rings around each pole, but in a great storm the rings grow and spread toward the equator: the more energy pours in, the wider they spread, and in 1859 they reached Cuba, Jamaica, Mexico and Chile. The aurora is not only green: oxygen glows green lower down and red higher up, about 60 to 250 miles (100 to 400 km) above the ground overall, with touches of blue and purple from nitrogen near the bottom. Someone far from the glow sees only its highest part over the horizon, which is the red, so a red glow low in the sky is exactly what people far from the poles should see.
  4. Power grids: storm currents flow into long power lines and can overheat giant transformers; in Quebec on March 13, 1989, a smaller storm collapsed the grid in about a minute and a half, leaving about 6 million people without power for about 9 hours, and studies warn a Carrington-class storm could cut power across whole regions, in the worst places for weeks. Satellites: the storm heats and swells the upper air, which drags on satellites; in February 2022 a minor storm brought down 38 new satellites. GPS: its signals pass through the charged upper air, so positions can drift or drop out. Forecasters now watch the Sun around the clock: coronagraphs give from less than a day to about three days of warning, spacecraft about a million miles (1.5 million km) out give 15 to 60 minutes (about 10 for a Carrington-fast cloud), and storms are rated G1 to G5. Grid operators can shift power, and satellite teams can put spacecraft into safe modes until it passes.

Going deeper

  1. How fast was Carrington's CME?: (a) 93 × 106 mi ÷ 17.6 h ≈ 5.3 million mph. 17.6 h = 63,360 s, so 1.50 × 108 km ÷ 63,360 s ≈ 2,370 km/s (1,470 mi/s), about 8.5 million km/h. (b) 1 day = 86,400 s: 1.50 × 108 ÷ 86,400 ≈ 1,740 km/s (1,080 mi/s). 4 days = 345,600 s: ≈ 434 km/s (270 mi/s). (c) 63,360 s ÷ 500 s ≈ 127 times longer. (d) KE = ½mv² = ½ × 1012 × (2.37 × 106 m/s)² ≈ 2.8 × 1024 J. At 434 km/s, KE ≈ ½ × 1012 × (4.34 × 105)² ≈ 9.4 × 1022 J. Kinetic energy grows with the square of speed, so (2,370 ÷ 434)² ≈ 30 times more.
  2. How much warning from a million miles out?: (a) t = 1.5 × 106 km ÷ 2,370 km/s ≈ 630 s (in miles: 930,000 mi ÷ 1,470 mi/s), about 10.5 minutes: the lecture's "closer to ten minutes". (b) 1.5 × 106 ÷ 1,740 ≈ 860 s ≈ 14 minutes; 1.5 × 106 ÷ 434 ≈ 3,460 s ≈ 58 minutes. That matches the usual range of 15 to 60 minutes. (c) A coronagraph shows that a cloud is coming and roughly when, but not which way its magnetism points. The storm's strength depends on whether the CME's field points opposite to Earth's, and that can only be measured when the cloud reaches the spacecraft.
  3. Why a sunspot looks dark: (a) (3,500 ÷ 5,800)⁴ ≈ 0.13 and (4,000 ÷ 5,800)⁴ ≈ 0.23: the umbra radiates about 13% to 23% as much per square meter. (b) b = 2.898 × 106 nm·K, so 2.898 × 106 ÷ 5,800 ≈ 500 nm (visible green-blue); 2.898 × 106 ÷ 4,000 ≈ 720 nm (deep red to near infrared). (c) The umbra still radiates σT⁴ ≈ 5.67 × 10-8 × 4,000⁴ ≈ 1.5 × 107 W per square meter, far more than any lamp. It looks dark only by contrast with the surface around it, which is four to eight times brighter. Seen alone against the night sky, a sunspot would glow brilliantly, orange-red.
  4. Why the red aurora shows from far away: (a) d = √(2 × 6,371 × 400) ≈ √5,100,000 ≈ 2,260 km, or √(2 × 3,960 × 250) ≈ 1,410 miles. (b) d = √(2 × 6,371 × 100) ≈ 1,130 km, or √(2 × 3,960 × 60) ≈ 690 miles. (c) The red top of the aurora can be seen about twice as far away as its green lower part. An observer more than about 700 miles (1,100 km) from the ground beneath the aurora, but less than about 1,400 miles (2,260 km), sees only the red top above the horizon, with the green hidden below it. That is why, far from the poles, the 1859 aurora appeared mostly as a red glow low in the sky.
  5. Faraday's law and the long wire: (a) A = 1.0 × 105 m × 1.0 × 104 m = 1.0 × 109 m² (about 390 sq mi). ΔΦ = 5.0 × 10-7 T × 1.0 × 109 m² = 500 Wb. ε = 500 Wb ÷ 300 s ≈ 1.7 V. (b) Doubling the length doubles the area and the emf, to about 3.3 V; halving the time doubles the rate of change, also giving about 3.3 V. (c) Twice the length gives twice the emf but also about twice the resistance, so I = ε ÷ R stays about the same. The length sets the voltage, the "push", not the current. (d) Current is the push divided by the resistance. Power lines are very long, so the push is large, and they are built with very low resistance, so the same push drives a much larger current, which flows through the grounded transformers at each end and can overheat them.
  6. Measuring a storm: the Dst index and the G-scale: (a) 850 ÷ 30,000 ≈ 0.028, about a 3% weakening, a small fraction, but an enormous change by the standard of magnetic storms. (b) −907 ± 132 nT spans about −775 to −1,039 nT, which includes −850 nT. The estimates overlap, and the 19th-century estimate is itself uncertain, so the storms cannot be ranked with confidence. That is why the lecture calls 1859 one of the strongest ever recorded, "perhaps the strongest". (c) 1,700 ÷ 11 ≈ 150 minor storms a year, about three a week on average (they cluster near the cycle's peak). 11 ÷ 4 ≈ 3 years between G5 storms on average. (d) Kp stops at 9, so every storm from an ordinary extreme storm upward is a G5. The scale cannot tell a Carrington-class storm from a G5 that occurs every few years; Dst, which has no top, can.